Heathrow Flight Path Consultation: January to March 2019: Details on consultation and responses

Major Heathrow consultation launched in January

8th January 2019

Heathrow Airport launched a major public consultation today.  It runs for 12 weeks until 4th March.

Key Points:

Runway alternation in West London will be cut from half a day to a third of the day to allow for alternation on a third runway if it is built.  The consultation is asking for views on how this should be implemented.

Significant changes to airspace are proposed to allow for vast swathes of London and the Home Counties, which currently get all-day flying, to get respite from the noise for the first time.  It applies to both arrivals and departures.

HACAN has released its response to the consultation.  Please feel free to use it to inform your own response should you wish.  It can be found at:  http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/HACAN-response-to-Heathrow-Consultation-1.pdf

And here is the response of our sister organisation HACAN East: http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Heathrow-Consultation-response-from-HACAN-East-1.pdf

For a 2 page summary of the runway alternation and respite proposals click: http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Heathrow-Consultation-briefing-arrivals-runway-alternation-and-respite-1-1.pdf 

For a 1 page summary on the departure proposals click:  http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Heathrow-Consultation-briefing-departures-1-1.pdf

The night period when there are no scheduled flights allowed will be extended from 5 hours to six and a half hours.  Views are sought on how this should operate.

For a 1 page summary of the night flight proposals click:  http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Heathrow-Consultation-briefing-night-flights-1.pdf

Views are sought on whether ‘westerly preference’ should remain – this is where planes continue to fly as if a west wind is blowing when there is an east wind (of up to 5 knots)

For a 1 page summary on the westerly preference proposals click: http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Heathrow-consultation-briefing-westerly-preference-1.pdf

Heathrow is proposing to bring in 25,000 extra flights a year in the years running up to the opening of any third runway.  Some of these flights will use new dedicated flight paths called Independent Parallel Approaches.

For a 2 page summary of Independent Parallel Approaches click:  http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Independent-Parallel-Approach-briefing-1.pdf

The full Heathrow document is here: http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Heathrow-Airspace-and-Future-Operations-Consultation-document-Final-low-res-1.pdf

Here’s a link to where and when the Heathrow consultation exhibitions will take place: http://afo.heathrowconsultation.com 

Here’s a powerpoint we have put together highlighting how different areas could be affected by the consultation proposals:  http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Heathrow-Airspace-Consultation-1.pdf

RESPITE REPORT PUBLISHED

 Respite Report launched

Heathrow published its long-awaited respite report commissioned from Anderson Acoustics on 16th February 2017.  It is the first of its kind to be done.  HACAN was part of the steering group.  Summary video: https://youtu.be/7Z5mt7rKJgA .

Where to find the reports: https://www.heathrow.com/noise/making-heathrow-quieter/respite-research

Most people favour respite

Heathrow’s consultation on the principles it should use in designing its new flight paths showed most people backed respite.  54% wanted the priority to be respite even if that increased the total number overflown; 25% wanted the priority to be to prevent new areas being overflown (that included most respondents not currently overflown); any only 22% backed minimising the total number overflown by concentrating all the flights over certain areas.  (Some backed more than one option which is why the don;t add up to 100%).

You can reading about further findings here:   https://files.acrobat.com/a/preview/95fcb6e4-d297-4678-9a08-3a819f0529d9

HACAN South East

Welcome to the HACAN South East Page

HACAN South East is an arm of HACAN.  It was set up in September 2017 to give a voice in particular to people living under the flight paths in SE London (roughly from Clapham to Eltham).

Flight_Path.jpg

A visual representation of aircraft movement linked to Heathrow – Green represent arrivals resulting from westerly winds (30% of the time), Red represent easterly (70% of the time).

Find out the key things we are campaigning for:  http://wp.me/P5NPQ9-13m 

If you want to find out more about us or are keen to help us email either: info@hacan.org.uk

Heathrow Consultations

Details are on the main HACAN Page but the Airspace Consultation is particularly important to people in SE London.

Consultation Venues: further east than ever before

In a recognition that people are impacted by aircraft noise much further from the airport than previously acknowledged.  On Friday 16 Feb (12- 8pm) there will be an exhibition for the first time in Vauxhall.  The venue , Wheatsheaf Community Centre, Wheatsheaf Lone, off South Lambeth Road is easily accessed from Brixton, Clappham, Oval, Waterloo and Camberwell.

HACAN, though, is in discussion with Heathrow to have two extra meetings: one further into SE London; one in NE London.

Parts of SE London are also overflown by aircraft arriving at London City Airport when an east wind is blowing.  This wasn’t too much of a problem until the flight paths were concentrated in February 2016.  Since then the planes have been concentrated over Eltham, Mottingham, Catford, Dulwich, Brixton, Stockwell, Oval and Waterloo.  The Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) are expected to comment on these concentrated flight paths by the end of this year.  We’ll bring news of that as soon as we get it.

  • Some days some areas get both Heathrow and City aircraft.  Scroll down to find out why.  

HACAN South East was launched on 27th September at a packed public meeting at the Oval.

Read our blog outlining practical ways to cut noise across South East London:  http://hacan.org.uk/blog/?p=547

Not just a West London problem – people relate their experiences on video of living with aircraft noise.

Click here to look at the videos: http://map.hacan.org.uk/

When people get annoyed by noise

The Government has recognised that people get annoyed by aircraft noise at lower levels than it previously thought. It now accepts the noise from Heathrow can annoy people in SE London.  Its Airspace Strategy, published in October 2017, recognised that people can get annoyed by aircraft noise when it averages out over a 16 hour day at 54 decibels.  Previously government argued it was 57 decibels. Some people get annoyed at even lower levels.

The figures are based on a study which the Government commissioned from the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA): Survey of Noise Attitudes 2014.

The chart above, taken from the study, compares the results of the Government sponsored ANIS Study with the new study. 9% of people are highly annoyed when the average is 54 decibels.  In geographical terms around Heathrow that goes as far as about Clapham to the east and about 16 miles to the west: about 65,000 people in total.  The lower average of 51% extends about as far as Peckham.

The full study:  http://publicapps.caa.co.uk/docs/33/CAP%201506%20FEB17.pdf

And you can read here the HACAN South East summary of the Government’s new Airspace Strategy:   http://hacan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Airspace-Policy.pdf

Why do parts of SE London sometimes get Heathrow and City planes on the same day?  It is all to do with the wind.  When the west wind blows, Heathrow planes land over SE London.  When it’s an east wind, many areas get City planes.  But Heathrow planes also land when an east wind is blowing up to about 5 knots.  So on these days both Heathrow and City aircraft are landing over SE London.

Out and About Campaigning

South East London campaigners joined forces with HACAN East and presented a flightpath cake to Tim Johnson, Head of Policy at the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) on Friday 28 July.

Plane_Hell.jpg We were joined by Keith Prince AM, current Chair of the GLA Transport Committee. The presentation was timed to ask CAA, in the lead up to their flightpath proposals for City Airport, to take into consideration all people and all areas of London who will be affected by their recommendations.

The CAA entered into the spirit of the event with a picture of the cake accompanying this tweet:

Plane_Hell2.PNG

Mr Prince extended an invitation to Campaigners to meet him at City Hall in September. He has promised to take our concerns regarding dedicated flight paths, as well as other plane-related issues, and how they affect residents of East and South East London to Mayor of London Rt Hon Sadiq Khan.

It’s been going on for 20 years…….

Although many residents feel that the problem of Heathrow planes has got worse in recent years as it seems flight paths have narrowed, the big change took place in the mid-1990s when planes began joining their final approach to Heathrow much further east than before.  Previously they had tended to join it around Barnes.  From about 1996 many started to join in SE London.  Thus, many people became ‘the new neighbours of Heathrow’.

Read residents stories:  http://www.hacan.org.uk/resources/reports/flight.paths.residents.experiences.pdf

And the summary of a major report commissioned by HACAN:  http://hacan.org.uk/resources/reports/hacan.flight.paths.study.pdf

Click on to a recent video: https://youtu.be/7SvPAFd9ajI

And one made 10 years ago: https://youtu.be/rXf8o_khz8s  

And one made in October 2017 where local residents graphically describe 30 years of living with London City Airport: https://youtu.be/6dMy7cGUVo4

 

List of Parliamentary Candidates in the General Election with their emails

Below is the candidates standing in the General Election in key constituencies impacted by Heathrow, together with their emails where they are available.   Feel free to email them to ask their views on a 3rd runway, on flight paths, on night flights or any other related topic. 


Hornsey and Wood Green

Lynne Featherstone MP, Lib Dem, Lynne@LynneFeatherstone.org

Catherine West, Lab, contact@catherinewest.org.uk

Clive Morrison, UKIP, clivemorrisonukip@gmail.com

Suhail Rahuja, Con, suhail.rahuja@manchesterconservatives.com

Gordon Peters, Green, gordon.peters@hornseywoodgreen.greenparty.org.uk

Marc Vandal, ClassWar

Dulwich and West Norwood

Helen Hayes, Lab, helen@helenhayes.org.uk

James Barber, Lab, cllrjamesbarber@gmail.com

Resham Kotecha, Con, reham4dwn@gmail.com

Rathy Alagarathan, UKIP

Rashid Nix, Green

 Runnymede and Weybridge

Philip Hammond MP, Con, hammondp@parliament.uk

Arran Neathey, Lab,

John Vincent, Lib Dem, john.vincent@john-vincent.org.uk ;

Rustam Majainah, Green, rustam.majainah@greenparty.org.uk

 Spelthorne

Kwasi Kwarteng MP, Con, kwasi.kwarteng.mp@parliament.uk

Paul Jacobs, Green, paul.jacobs@greenparty.org.uk

Redvers Cunningham, UKIP, redvers.cuningham@me.com

Rosie Shimell, Lib Dem,

Rebecca Geach, Lab,

 Streatham

Chuka Umunna MP, Lab, chuka.umunna.mp@parliament.uk

Amna Ahmad, Lib Dems, amna@lambethlibdems.org

Kim Caddy, Con,

Bruce Machan, UKIP

Jonathan Bartley, Green, jonathan.bartley@greenparty.org.uk

Unjum Mirza, TUSC,

 Twickenham

Vince Cable MP, Lib Dem,  cablev@parliament.uk

Tania Mathias, Con, tania@tania4twickenham.co.uk ;

Nick Grant, Lab, nick4twick@gmail.com

Tanya Williams, Green, tanya.williams@greenparty.org.uk

Barry Edwards, UKIP,   email@barryedwards.info

Vauxhall

Kate Hoey MP, Lab, hoeyk@parliament.uk

Adrian Trett, Lib Dems, Adrian.trett@gmail.com

James Bellis, Con, vca@tory.org

Gulnar Hasnain, Green, gulnar.hasnain@greenparty.org.uk

Ace Nnorom, UKIP

Bermondsey

 Simon Hughes MP, Lib Dem, simon@simonhughes.org.uk

Neil Coyle, Lab, Neil.Coyle@neilcoyle.org.uk

Jean-Paul Flora, Con, jpflora@gmail.com

Rosamund Beattie, UKIP

William Lavin, Green, william.lavin@greenparty.org.uk

Kingsley Abrams, TUSC

 Beaconsfield

Dominic Grieve MP, Con, grieved@parliament.uk

Peter Chapman, Lib Dems, peter.pjchapman@btopenworld.com

Tim Scott, UKIP

Dave Hampton, Green, dave@carboncoach.com

Westminster North

Karen Buck MP, Lab, buckk@parliament.uk

Lindsey Hall, Con, campaigns@lindseyhall.co.uk

Jennifer Nadal, Green, jennifernadal@yahoo.com

Nigel Sussman, UKIP

Kirsty Allen, Lib Dem

Cities of London

Mark Field MP, Con, fieldm@parliament.uk

Belinda Brookes-Gordon, Lib Dem,  b.brookes-gordon@bbk.ac.uk

Nick Slingsby, Lab,

Hugh Small, Green, hugh.small@greenparty.org.uk

Bracknell

Philip Lee MP, Con, philip.lee.mp@parliament.uk

Patrick Smith, Lib Dem, patrick.smith@bracknelllibdems.org.uk

James Walsh, Lab,

Richard Thomas, UKIP, richardthomas@ukipbracknell.co.uk

Derek Florey, Green

Wimbledon

Stephen Hammond MP, Con, hammonds@parliament.uk

Shas Sheehan, Lib Dem, shas@shassheehan.org.uk

Andrew Judge, Lab, wimbledonandrew@gmail.com

Peter Bucklitsch, UKIP, peter.oddlyoak@googlemail.com

Ealing Southall

Virenda Sharma MP, Lab, sharmav@parliament.uk

James Symes, Con, jamessymes@gmail.com

John Poynton, UKIP, john@ukip-ealing-southall.org

Kavya Kaushik, Lib Dem, kavya.p.kaushik@gmail.com

Jaspreet Mahal, Green, jaspreet.mahal@greenparty.org.uk

Hammersmith

Andy Slaughter MP, Lab, slaughtera@parliament.uk

Charlie Dewhirst, Con

Millicent Scott, Lib Dems, millicentscottlibdem@gmail.com

David Akan, Green, david.akan@greenparty.org.uk

Richard Wood, UKIP,  richard@building-trade.com

Uxbridge

Boris Johnson, Con, admin@hillingdonconservatives.org ;

Jack Duffin, UKIP,  jackduffinwork@gmail.com

Graham Lee, Green, graham.lee@greenparty.org.uk

Michael Cox, Lib Dem mikecox1@btinternet.com

Chris Summers, Lab, chrissummers4942@btinternet.com

Putney

Justine Greening MP, Con, greeningj@parliament.uk,

Sheila Boswell, Lab, boswellsheila@me.com

Chris Poole, Green, chris.poole@greenparty.org.uk

Andy Hallett, Lib Dems, andrewjhallett@gmail.com

Battersea

Jane Ellison MP, Con, jane@janeellison.net

Will Martindale, Lab, will@willtowin.org.uk

Joe Stuart, Green, joe.stuart@greenparty.org.uk

Luke Taylor, Lib Dems, luke.taylor104@gmail.com

Chris Howe, UKIP

Fulham

Greg Hands MP, Con, mail@greghands.com

Alexandra Sanderson

Guy Rubin, Green, guy.rubin@greenparty.org.uk

Simon Bailey, Lib Dem

Kensington

Rod Abouharb, Lab, kensingtonlabour@gmail.com

Robin McGhee, Lib Dem, robinmaxcghee@gmail.com

Robina Rose, Green, robina.rose@greenparty.org.uk

Kingston

Ed Davey MP, edward@edwarddavey.co.uk

James Berry, Con, office@kingstonconservatives.com

Lee Godfrey, Lab, contact@leegodfrey.info

Ben Roberts, UKIP

Clare Keogh, Green, claire.keogh@greenparty.org.uk

Laurel Fogarty, TUSC, Kingston.TUSC@hotmail.com

Slough

Fiona Mactaggart MP, Lab, mactaggartf@parliament.uk

Gurchuran Singh, Con, gs@gurchuransingh.co.uk

Ken Wight, UKIP, kenwright@yahoo.co.uk

Tom McCann, Lib Dem, tom.mccann@sloughlibdemsorg.uk

Windsor

Adam Afriyie MP, Con, afriyiea@parliament.uk

Fiona Dent, Lab, fionadentlabour@btinternet.com

Derek Wall, Green, wallddd@hotmail.com

Widom da Costa, Independent, wisdomdacosta@hotmail.co.uk

George Fussey, Lib Dems, george.fussey@windsorlibdems.org.uk

Hayes and Harlington

John McDonnell MP, Lab, mcdonnellj@parliament.uk

Pearl Lewis, Con, pearl4hayes@outlook.com

Cliff Dixon, UKIP, cliff.dixon@englishpatriot.co.uk

Alick Munro, Green, alick@munro.com

Richmond Park and North Kingston

Zac Goldsmith MP, Con,  zac@zacgoldsmith.com

Robin Meltzer, Lib Dem, robin@robinmeltzer.com

Sachin Patel, Lab, sachin@sachin4richmondpark.org.uk

Andree Friexe, Green, andree.frisze@greenparty.org.uk

Sam Naz, UKIP

Ealing and Acton

Angie Bray MP, Con, angie.bray.mp@parliament.uk

Rupa Huq, Lab, rupahuq@ealinglabour.com

Tom Sharman, Green, tom4ealing@greenparty.org.uk

Peter Florence, UKIP

Jon Ball, Lib Dem, jonball@cix.co.uk

Brentford and Isleworth

Mary Macleod MP, Con, mary.macleod.mp@parliament.uk

Ruth Cadbury, Lab, ruth.cadbury@gmail.com

Joseph Bourke, Lib Dem, j.bourke@bourkeaccounts.com

Daniel Goldsmith, Green,  daniel.goldsmith@greenparty.org.uk

Richard Hendron, (hendronrichard@hotmail.com),

Feltham and Heston

Seema Malhotra MP, Lab, seema.malhotra.mp@parliament.uk

Simon Nayyar, Con, info@simonnayyar.com

Roger Crouch, Lib Dem, rmcrouch33@gmail.com

Tony Firkins, Green, tony.firkins@greenparty.org.uk

Peter Dul, UKIP

 Bethnal Green and Bow

Ali Rushanara MP       Lab        rushanara@rushanaraali.org

Matthew Smith            Con         matt4bgb@gmail.com

Teena Lashmore        Lib Dems

Alastair Polson          Green       dan.lee@towerhamlets.greenparty.org.uk

Glyn Robbins, TUSC,

  Poplar and Limehouse

Jim Fitzpatrick MP      Lab        fitzpatrickj@parliament.uk

Christopher Wilford     Con        wilford2015@gmail.com

Elaine Bagshaw           Lib Dem

Maureen Childes        Green Party, maureen.childs@greenparty.org.uk

  Leyton and Wanstead

John Cryer MP         Lab        john.cryer@unitetheunion.com

Matthew Scott          Con         matthew.scott@leytonandwanstead.co.uk

Martin Levin            UKIP       martinlevin@hotmail.co.uk

Ashley Gunstock    Green      ashley.gunstock@btinternet.com

Carl Quillian          Lib Dem

  East Ham

Stephen Timms MP Labour    stephen@stephentimmsorg.uk

Tamsin Omond     Green         info@thecommons.com

Samir Jassal        Con

Lois Austin          TUSC

David Thorpe,   Lib Dem

 West Ham

Lyn Brown MP   Lab             lyn@lynbrown.org.uk

Festus Akinbbusoye Con     festus@fest4westham.com

Jane Lithgow    Green         jane.lithgow@greenparty.org.uk

Paul Reynolds Lib Dems     paulemreynolds@gmail.com

 Hornchurch

Angela Watkinson MP  Con  info@hx-upmtory.com

Paul McGeary     Lab

Lawrence Webb  UKIP        lawrencewebb@btinternet.com

Melanie Collins   Green       melanie.collins@greenparty.org.uk

  Eltham

Clive Efford MP  Lab       clive@cliveefford.org.uk

Alex Cunliffe     Lib Dem   Alex4Eltham@gmail.com

Peter Whittle   UKIP        info@peterwhittle.org

Spencer Drury  Con       spencer@spencerdrury.com

 Lewisham East

Heidi Alexander MP  Lab   heidi@heidialexander.org.uk

Peter Fortune    Con          peter@peterfortune.co.uk

Julia Fletcher   Lib Dem    julia.fletcher@virginmedia.com

Storm Poorun Green       storm.poorun@greenparty.org.uk

  Lewisham West

Jim Dowd MP   Lab      jimdowd.newlabour@care4free.net

Russell Jackson  Con   russell@russel-jackson.co.uk

Tom Chance  Green    tom.chance@greenparty.org.uk

Alex Feakes Lib Dem  alex@alexfeakes.org

Martin Powell  TUSC

  Lewisham Deptford

Vicky Foxcroft      Lab      vickyfoxcroft@hotmail.com

Birn Afolami         Con       birmafolami2@gmail.com

Michael Bukola     Lib Dem michaelbukola@hotmail.com

John Coughlin    Green     cllr_john.coughlin@lewisham.gov.uk

Chris Flood       TUSC

 Greenwich

Matthew Pennycook Lab matthew@matthewpennycook.com

Matt Hartley            Con  matt@matthartley.org.uk

Ryan Acty              UKIP ryan@ryanacty.org.uk

Abbey Akinoshun   Green  hello@abbey4mp.org

Walthamstow

Stella Creasy MP, Lab, stella.creasy.mp@parliament.uk

Steven Cheung, Lib Dem,

Molly Samual-Leport, Con,

Nancy Taffe, TUSC,

Paul Hillman, UKIP

Michael Gold, Green, michael.gold@greenparty.org.uk

Hackney South and Shoreditch

Meg Hillier MP, Lab, votemeghillier@hotmail.com

Charlotte George, Green, charlotte.george@greenparty.org.uk

Ben Mathis, Lib Dem, ben@hackneylibdems.org

Jack Tinley, Con, jack4hackney@gmail.com

Angus Small, UKIP

Hackney North and Stoke Newington

Diane Abbott MP, Lab, chalkiasg@parliament.uk

Heather Finlay, Green, contactus@hackney.greenparty.org.uk

Amy Gray, Con, amygrayforhachneynorth@gmail.com

Simon de Deney, Lib Dem, simon@simondedeney.org

Keith Fraser, UKIP, keith.fraser@ukiplocal.org

Islington South and Finsbury

Emily Thornberry MP, Lab, emily@islingtonsouth.org.uk

Charlie Kiss, Green, Charlie.kiss@greenparty.org.uk

Peter Muswell, UKIP, pete.muswell@ukip-islington.gov.uk

Terry Stacey, Lib Dems,

Mark Lim, Con,

Islington North

Jeremy Corbyn MP, Lab, jeremy@islingtonlabour.org.uk

Caroline Russell, Green, caroline.russell@greenparty.org.uk

Julian Gregory, Lib Dem, julian.gregory@islington-libdemds.org.uk

Alex Burghart, Con,

Hampstead and Kilburn

Tulip Siddiq, Lab, tulip@tulipsiddiq.com

Simon Marcus, Con, simonmarcus2003@yahoo.co.uk

Maajid Nawaz, Lib Dem, MaajidNawaazHK@gmail.com

Rebecca Johnson, Green, Rebecca.johnson@greenparty.org.uk

Magnus Neilson, UKIP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

London outstripping all world cities as an aviation hub

London is outstripping all world cities as an aviation hub.  It debunks the capacity crunch myth.  Far from Britain declining as an aviation superpower, the capital’s global lead over every other city in the world is increasing.

Despite the “capacity crunch” at the capital’s airport, figures compiled by The Independent reveal that London remains the world’s top airline hub by a wide margin – and is racing ahead of its closest rival, New York.

A record 144.7m passengers flew through London’s five commercial airports in 2014. The figure translates to an average of 275 people – or one wide-bodied aircraft – arriving or departing every minute of every day of the year. The capital is 23 per cent ahead of New York, which has three airports.

The Independent has analysed passenger figures for the 20 key aviation cities, aggregating the traffic for all airports serving each metropolis. London’s catchment comprises Heathrow, Gatwick, Stansted, Luton and London City. Flight movements at Heathrow have reached their effective limit at 1,290 per day, and the airport’s passenger figures are now dwarfed by Atlanta and Beijing. Yet Heathrow grew 1.7 per cent thanks to larger aircraft. Combined with rapid growth at the capital’s other airports, London put on almost seven million passengers during the year, a rise of 5 per cent.

Read the full article:  http://ind.pn/1EcVggf .

HACAN reveals: 3rd runway could mean 13 hours of non-stop flying

If a third runway is built some areas will experience 13 hours of non-stop flying – a plane every 90 seconds.  These will include places under the new flight path like Harlington and Brentford.  It would also apply to places such as Richmond under the approach to the southern runway.